Everyone interprets a debate differently
There is no perfect assessment of a debate. Even experienced judges disagree about which team won a debate and why, but overtime you will find it easier to judge more consistently.
Follow the criteria established in the rubric
While some elements of debate or speech are subjective, objective measures allow judges to reach similar decisions. Skills demonstrated by speakers are broken down in the rubric to make it easier for judges to determine how well a speaker met the criteria for a skill.
Feedback is important
Speakers are looking for honest, constructive feedback on they can improve their debating skills. We recommend that feedback be structured to provide encouragement.